Toyota Yaris ATIV 2021-2025

The newest version of the compact sedan, and probably the best balance of fuel use, boot space and running cost in the whole fleet. The updated ATIV has a modern media system with wireless Apple CarPlay, a rear camera and a quieter cabin than the 2021 car.

What that means in practice: navigation in Phuket depends on your phone, and the rear camera turns reversing into a narrow space next to a restaurant from a stressful moment into a routine one. A newer car also means air conditioning in good condition and fresh tyres, which matters for safety on wet roads in the rainy season.

On fuel use only the hybrids, the Corolla Altis and the Corolla Cross, do better. But those cars cost more to rent and are larger. If the goal is simply to drive cheaply and park easily, the ATIV is the more sensible choice.

Against the Honda City 2024: the City accelerates faster thanks to its turbo engine and feels better on long climbs with a full load. The ATIV is simpler, cheaper to run and calmer to drive.